News

The Supreme Court Left Custodia Off Fed Rails, and Waller Says Skinny Accounts Helped the Fed

The Supreme Court declined Custodia's master-account appeal this week. Governor Waller said skinny Fed payment accounts are finishing by year end and helped the Fed's case.

The Supreme Court will not hear Custodia Bank's fight for a Federal Reserve master account. Governor Christopher Waller says the Fed's limited "skinny" payment accounts may have helped keep it that way.

The Bank Policy Institute recapped on November 21 that the Court declined, on Monday, to take Custodia's appeal of a Tenth Circuit ruling that left the Fed free to deny the Wyoming crypto lender a master account. Banking Dive had the same denial: Custodia sued in 2022 after waiting 19 months, the Kansas City Fed refused the application in January 2023, and the Tenth Circuit backed the central bank's discretion. Judge Timothy Tymkovich dissented in October 2025, writing that the Fed had claimed "unreviewable discretion over access to the nation's financial system."

A master account is the pipe. With one, a firm settles, holds reserves, and sends payments on Fed rails without a correspondent bank. Without one, it rents someone else's pipe. Block is trying a different door, an OCC trust-bank application that still would not be Fed access.

Waller: we were finishing the skinny account anyway

Waller spoke Tuesday at The Clearing House's annual conference. BPI says he told the room the Fed plans to finalize its framework for Reserve Bank payment accounts, the skinny master accounts, by the end of the year. "We know that to keep up, we have to adapt," he said. "We have to adopt new technologies, and we're thinking about how to do that every single day." The accounts, as proposed, would not pay interest and would not borrow from the discount window. BPI still argues they would let firms without full bank protections onto Fed payment rails.

On Custodia, Waller was blunter. Kyle Campbell reported that the Solicitor General used the skinny account as proof the Fed was opening a lane for new entrants. "It wasn't what I was trying to do, but it ended up at the end of the day having an impact on how the court looked at the decision," Waller said. "The benefit of the skinny account was that the Solicitor General defending our right to control master account access used the skinny account as an example that the Fed was, in fact, creating innovative solutions to allow new entrants and competition into the system."

Kraken, a Wyoming special-purpose depository, received the first skinny master account in March, in a 12-month pilot. Custodia's CEO, Caitlin Long, had not commented on the Supreme Court order when Banking Dive published. Idaho-based PayServices is still appealing a loss against the San Francisco Fed in the Ninth Circuit.

Paige Pidano Paridon, BPI's executive vice president, called master-account access "a privilege, not a right." Julie Hill, dean of the University of Wyoming College of Law, told American Banker the opposite risk: that the Fed can now "do what it wants with master accounts," including swinging with each administration. The Court left that argument where it found it.

Some offers on this page may be paid placements or contain affiliate links.

Finpresso: daily AI & finance brief

Free daily newsletter, read in 5 minutes.

Subscribe free